# Tesla Model 3 vs Model Y: used prices and resale value, side by side [Home](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/) › [Comparisons](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/compare) › Tesla Model 3 vs Model Y > Markdown copy of https://www.luxurycardeals.com/compare/tesla-model-3-vs-tesla-model-y for AI agents and assistants. Link and cite that URL, not this one. 1,622 live listings · Updated Oct 1, 2026 A used Tesla Model Y asks a median of $32,102 in our latest scan, 9% more than a Tesla Model 3 at $29,423. The Model 3 holds its value better: with the same trim and miles, a 2023 lists at about 84% of a 2026's price, against about 79% for the Model Y. There are 622 Model 3s for sale from model years 2018-2026 and 1,000 Model Ys from 2020-2026. Asking prices come from 1,622 live dealer listings in our latest scan; value kept compares model years with the same trim and miles in our market model. **Median asking price: $29k vs $32k** (Model 3 vs Model Y, across 1,622 live listings) - Model 3 for sale: 622 - Model Y for sale: 1,000 - Kept after 3 years: 84% vs 79% - Below market now: 139 vs 260 ## Model 3 and Model Y at a glance ### [Tesla Model 3](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/used/tesla/model-3) 622 Model 3s for sale, model years 2018-2026. The cheapest is a 2021 Tesla Model 3 (Performance) listed at $12,949 with 145,668 mi in Dumfries, VA. - Median asking price: $29,423 - For sale: 622 - Kept after 3 years: 84% - Below market now: 139 [Cheapest Tesla Model 3 for sale](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/cheapest/tesla/model-3) · [Tesla Model 3 price guide](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/prices/tesla/model-3) ### [Tesla Model Y](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/used/tesla/model-y) 1,000 Model Ys for sale, model years 2020-2026. The cheapest is a 2021 Tesla Model Y (Performance) listed at $17,488 with 165,256 mi in Miami, FL. - Median asking price: $32,102 - For sale: 1,000 - Kept after 3 years: 79% - Below market now: 260 [Cheapest Tesla Model Y for sale](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/cheapest/tesla/model-y) · [Tesla Model Y price guide](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/prices/tesla/model-y) ## The short answer Who wins on each measure. Close calls (within a few percent) say either. | If you want | Pick | Why | | --- | --- | --- | | The lower price | [Model 3](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/used/tesla/model-3) | Median asking price $29,423, 8% below the Model Y's $32,102 | | The one that holds its value | [Model 3](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/used/tesla/model-3) | Keeps about 84% after three years, against 79% for the Model Y | | More to choose from | [Model Y](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/used/tesla/model-y) | 1,000 for sale, against 622 Model 3s | | More priced below market | [Model Y](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/used/tesla/model-y) | 26% of its listings, against 22% of the Model 3's | | The cheapest one for sale | [Model 3](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/used/tesla/model-3) | A 2021 Tesla Model 3 (Performance) listed at $12,949 with 145,668 mi in Dumfries, VA | ## Every number, head to head | | Model 3 | Model Y | | --- | --- | --- | | For sale now | 622 | 1,000 | | Median asking price | $29,423 | $32,102 | | Middle half of asking prices | $25k to $34k | $29k to $36k | | Cheapest for sale | $12,949 | $17,488 | | Median miles | 51,965 mi | 51,826 mi | | Model years for sale | 2018-2026 | 2020-2026 | | Value kept after 3 years | 84% | 79% | | Value kept after 5 years | 75% | 71% | | Priced below market now | 139 (22%) | 260 (26%) | | Typical days to sell | 36 | 35 | | Asking prices, last 3 months | +1.1% | +1.8% | ## Asking prices by model year Median asking price and listings for each model year in our latest scan, newest first. | Model year | Model 3 median | Model 3 for sale | Model Y median | Model Y for sale | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | 2026 | $52,071 | 15 | $58,968 | 19 | | 2025 | $47,014 | 35 | $44,317 | 31 | | 2024 | $42,812 | 45 | $39,702 | 96 | | 2023 | $32,370 | 150 | $34,670 | 252 | | 2022 | $29,661 | 126 | $30,594 | 441 | | 2021 | $26,930 | 84 | $28,048 | 108 | | 2020 | $24,989 | 93 | $27,272 | 53 | | 2019 | $22,565 | 40 | – | – | | 2018 | $21,559 | 34 | – | – | ## The cheapest Model 3 and Model Y for sale The 3 lowest asking prices of each in our latest scan of dealer listings. - [2021 Tesla Model 3, Performance](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/cars/tesla-model-3-p3d-performance): $12,949 · 145,668 mi · Dumfries, VA - [2018 Tesla Model 3, Performance](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/cars/tesla-model-3-p3d-performance): $13,190 · 200,069 mi · Portland, OR - [2018 Tesla Model 3, Performance](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/cars/tesla-model-3-p3d-performance): $13,700 · 188,209 mi · Kennewick, WA - [2021 Tesla Model Y, Performance](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/cars/tesla-model-y-performance): $17,488 · 165,256 mi · Miami, FL - [2022 Tesla Model Y, Performance](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/cars/tesla-model-y-performance): $17,497 · 165,368 mi · Paterson, NJ - [2021 Tesla Model Y, Performance](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/cars/tesla-model-y-performance): $17,896 · 176,560 mi · La Puente, CA ## Model 3 and Model Y priced below market 399 deals priced below market right now, the best by about $5,683. Members get the VIN, dealer, listing link and a ready-to-send negotiation email for each one. - 2023 Tesla Model Y, Performance: asking $29,683 · $6k below market · 40,456 mi · Willowbrook, IL · deal score 100 of 100 - 2022 Tesla Model Y, Performance: asking $29,094 · $6k below market · 30,137 mi · Wall Township, NJ · deal score 100 of 100 - 2022 Tesla Model Y, Performance: asking $28,794 · $5k below market · 33,303 mi · Wall Township, NJ · deal score 100 of 100 - 2021 Tesla Model Y, Performance: asking $26,994 · $5k below market · 34,172 mi · Sewell, NJ · deal score 100 of 100 - 2023 Tesla Model 3, Performance: asking $28,100 · $5k below market · 36,777 mi · Boise, ID · deal score 100 of 100 - 2023 Tesla Model 3, Performance: asking $29,087 · $5k below market · 29,044 mi · Springfield, NJ · deal score 100 of 100 [Unlock all 399 deals](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/upgrade). Members see every deal's VIN, dealer and listing link, plus a negotiation email. ## Prices, listings and rankings - [Used Tesla Model 3 for sale](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/used/tesla/model-3) - [Cheapest Tesla Model 3 for sale](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/cheapest/tesla/model-3) - [Tesla Model 3 price guide](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/prices/tesla/model-3) - [Best used luxury sedans (#1 of 11)](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/best/used-luxury-sedans) - [Luxury cars that hold their value (#14 of 46)](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/best/luxury-cars-that-hold-their-value) - [Used Tesla Model Y for sale](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/used/tesla/model-y) - [Cheapest Tesla Model Y for sale](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/cheapest/tesla/model-y) - [Tesla Model Y price guide](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/prices/tesla/model-y) - [Best used luxury SUVs (#4 of 11)](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/best/used-luxury-suvs) ## More comparisons - [Tesla Model X vs Model Y](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/compare/tesla-model-x-vs-tesla-model-y) - [Tesla Model S vs Model 3](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/compare/tesla-model-s-vs-tesla-model-3) - [Porsche Taycan vs Tesla Model S](https://www.luxurycardeals.com/compare/porsche-taycan-vs-tesla-model-s) ## Tesla Model 3 vs Model Y: common questions ### Which is cheaper used, the Tesla Model 3 or the Tesla Model Y? The Model 3: its median asking price is $29,423, against $32,102 for the Model Y in our scan of Oct 1, 2026. The cheapest Model 3 is a 2021 Tesla Model 3 (Performance) listed at $12,949 with 145,668 mi in Dumfries, VA. The cheapest Model Y is a 2021 Tesla Model Y (Performance) listed at $17,488 with 165,256 mi in Miami, FL. ### Which holds its value better, the Tesla Model 3 or the Tesla Model Y? The Model 3 holds its value better: with the same trim and miles, a 2023 lists at about 84% of a 2026's price, against about 79% for the Model Y. That compares asking prices across model years in our market model, so it shows how the market prices an older car, not one car's history. ### How many Model 3s and Model Ys are for sale? There are 622 Model 3s for sale from model years 2018-2026 and 1,000 Model Ys from 2020-2026. That's from our latest scan of US dealer listings. ### Which sells faster, the Tesla Model 3 or the Tesla Model Y? About the same: a typical one leaves the market in about 36 days for the Model 3 and 35 days for the Model Y. ### Where do these numbers come from? Prices are live asking prices from US dealer listings in our latest scan, not sale prices. Value kept and days to sell come from our market model, which compares the same trims and miles across model years. --- Source: Luxury Car Deals, https://www.luxurycardeals.com/. Prices are live asking prices from US dealer listings in our latest scan, not sale prices. Cite as "Tesla Model 3 vs Model Y: used prices and resale value, side by side", Luxury Car Deals, https://www.luxurycardeals.com/compare/tesla-model-3-vs-tesla-model-y (updated Oct 1, 2026). Site map for assistants: https://www.luxurycardeals.com/llms.txt.