13 live listingsUpdated
Used Tesla Model Y for sale in New York
13 Tesla Model Y listings are live in New York in our latest scan, from $20,174 up to $40,630. The median asking price is $28,670. Model years range from 2021 to 2024, the typical car shows 48,371 mi, and half are priced between $26,216 and $30,590.
That's 1% of the 1,000 used Tesla Model Ys we track nationwide. The most are listed in Fort Montgomery (2), Airmont (1), and Bay Shore (1). Comparing the same model, year and trim, the typical Tesla Model Y here is listed 4% below similar cars elsewhere in the US (13 cars compared).
The lowest-priced one is a 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance listed at $20,174 with 150,046 mi in Brooklyn, NY.
Best Tesla Model Y deals in New York
10 deals priced below market right now, the best by about $4,270. Members get the VIN, dealer, listing link and a ready-to-send negotiation email for each one.
-
$4k below market Locked2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Great deal: about $4k under fair value for its year, trim and miles.
Asking price $28,670Deal score 100 -
$3k below market Locked2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Great deal: about $3k under fair value for its year, trim and miles.
Asking price $20,174Deal score 99 -
$3k below market Locked2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Great deal: about $3k under fair value for its year, trim and miles.
Asking price $29,570Deal score 97 -
$3k below market Locked2021 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Great deal: about $3k under fair value for its year, trim and miles.
Asking price $26,170Deal score 97 -
$3k below market Locked2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Great deal: about $3k under fair value for its year, trim and miles.
Asking price $30,590Deal score 96 -
$3k below market Locked2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Great deal: about $3k under fair value for its year, trim and miles.
Asking price $30,173Deal score 94
Members see every deal's VIN, dealer and listing link, plus a negotiation email.
Latest used Tesla Model Ys in New York
-
2021 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $26,170 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $20,174 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $26,989 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $28,670 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $31,500 -
2023 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $33,269 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $29,570 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $30,173 -
2021 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $27,174 -
2024 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $40,630 -
2021 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $26,216 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $30,590 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $26,163
Tesla Model Y prices by model year in New York
Median asking price for each model year among the Tesla Model Ys for sale in New York.
- 2024 $40,630
- 2023 $33,269
- 2022 $29,120
- 2021 $26,216
New York vs. the rest of the US
Comparing the same model, year and trim, the typical Tesla Model Y here is listed 4% below similar cars elsewhere. The medians below also reflect which years and trims are listed in each place.
| Location | For sale | Median price | Lowest price | Median miles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York | 13 | $28,670 | $20,174 | 48,371 |
| Rest of the US | 987 | $32,186 | $17,488 | 51,859 |
Where in New York Tesla Model Ys are for sale
| City | For sale | Median price | Lowest price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fort Montgomery | 2 | $27,870 | $26,170 |
| Airmont | 1 | $26,989 | $26,989 |
| Bay Shore | 1 | $26,163 | $26,163 |
| Bellerose | 1 | $26,216 | $26,216 |
| Brooklyn | 1 | $20,174 | $20,174 |
| College Point | 1 | $31,500 | $31,500 |
| Elmsford | 1 | $40,630 | $40,630 |
| Farmington | 1 | $33,269 | $33,269 |
| Lockport | 1 | $27,174 | $27,174 |
| West Hempstead | 1 | $28,670 | $28,670 |
| Woodbury | 1 | $30,173 | $30,173 |
| Yonkers | 1 | $30,590 | $30,590 |
Used Tesla Model Ys in other states
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Alabama9
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Arizona35
- Used Tesla Model Ys in California236
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Colorado18
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Connecticut10
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Florida102
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Georgia67
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Hawaii6
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Idaho6
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Illinois42
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Indiana15
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Kentucky6
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Maryland10
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Massachusetts11
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Minnesota5
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Missouri10
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Nevada24
- Used Tesla Model Ys in New Jersey31
- Used Tesla Model Ys in New Mexico6
- Used Tesla Model Ys in North Carolina45
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Ohio13
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Oklahoma5
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Oregon13
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Pennsylvania8
- Used Tesla Model Ys in South Carolina7
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Tennessee17
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Texas71
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Utah45
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Virginia54
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Washington32
- Used Tesla Model Ys in Wisconsin5
Used Tesla Model Ys in New York: common questions
How much does a used Tesla Model Y cost in New York?
Used Tesla Model Y asking prices in New York currently range from $20,174 to $40,630, with a median of $28,670 across 13 listings. Half of them are priced between $26,216 and $30,590.
Are used Tesla Model Ys cheaper in New York?
Slightly. Comparing the same model, year and trim, used Tesla Model Ys in New York are listed a median 4% below similar cars elsewhere in the US, across 13 cars with matches. Mileage, options and condition still vary from car to car.
Where in New York are the most used Tesla Model Ys for sale?
Fort Montgomery (2), Airmont (1), Bay Shore (1), Bellerose (1), and Brooklyn (1) have the most listings in our latest scan.
What is the cheapest Tesla Model Y for sale right now in New York?
The lowest asking price in our latest scan is a 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance listed at $20,174 with 150,046 mi in Brooklyn, NY.
Which Tesla Model Y model years are for sale in New York?
Listings span 2021 to 2024. The 2022 model year has the most cars for sale (8, median $29,120). The newest 2024 cars have a median asking price of $40,630, versus $26,216 for 2021.
How many miles do used Tesla Model Ys for sale in New York have?
The median Tesla Model Y for sale in New York shows 48,371 mi. 0 of 13 listings (0%) have under 15,000 miles.
How long do Tesla Model Ys stay on the market in New York?
Current Tesla Model Y listings in New York have been for sale for a median of 25 days. Cars that sit well beyond that are often the easiest to negotiate on.
How current is this data?
These numbers come from our latest scan of dealer listings on Oct 1, 2026. Luxury Car Deals rescans the market regularly and removes cars that have sold.