1,018 live listingsUpdated
Tesla Model Y Performance
15 deals foundBest first
The best Model Y Performance deals right now
Only listings we rate Great or Good make the list. Each is priced against our fair value for its year, trim and miles. Last checked 21 days ago, so some may have sold.
1 deal is open to everyone. 14 are locked, with the VIN, dealer, listing link and a negotiation email. A free account unlocks one a month.
-
#1
2023 Tesla Model Y
$29,683 $5,683 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $5,683 (16.1%) under our fair value of $35,366 for its year, trim and mileage, the largest discount among the 15 ranked deals. At 40,456 miles it sits 2,275 miles under the median for 2023 listings.
- Fair value
- $35,366
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#2
2022 Tesla Model Y
$29,094 $5,525 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $5,525 (16%) under our fair value of $34,619 for its year, trim and mileage, and it has the lowest mileage of the 15 ranked deals at 30,137 miles, 31,997 under the median for 2022 listings.
- Fair value
- $34,619
- From 6,536 similar cars
- Open at
- $27,900
- 4% under the ask
- Aim to pay
- $28,716
- Days listed
- 61
- Typical: 35
Some room to negotiate.
Free look: every member deal comes with these details
VIN 7SAYGDEF8NF493067
-
#3
2022 Tesla Model Y
$28,794 $5,405 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $5,405 (15.8%) under our fair value of $34,199 for its year, trim and mileage, with 33,303 miles, 28,831 under the median for 2022 listings. Its price has already been cut once and now sits 5% below its highest asking price.
- Fair value
- $34,199
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#4
2021 Tesla Model Y
$26,994 $5,265 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $5,265 (16.3%) under our fair value of $32,259 for its year, trim and mileage, and it has 34,172 miles, well under the 72,800-mile median for 2021 listings.
- Fair value
- $32,259
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#5
2023 Tesla Model Y
$30,305 $4,848 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $4,848 (13.8%) under our fair value of $35,153 for its year, trim and mileage, with mileage of 42,490 miles in line with the median for 2023 listings.
- Fair value
- $35,153
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#6
2022 Tesla Model Y
$28,294 $4,819 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $4,819 (14.6%) under our fair value of $33,113 for its year, trim and mileage, and 43,337 miles is well under the 62,134-mile median for 2022 listings.
- Fair value
- $33,113
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#7
2022 Tesla Model Y
$28,000 $4,753 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $4,753 (14.5%) under our fair value of $32,753 for its year, trim and mileage, with 46,718 miles against a 62,134-mile median for 2022 listings.
- Fair value
- $32,753
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#8
2023 Tesla Model Y
$29,198 $4,637 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $4,637 (13.7%) under our fair value of $33,835 for its year, trim and mileage. Its 53,041 miles are 10,310 above the median for 2023 listings, and it has been listed for 53 days.
- Fair value
- $33,835
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#9
2023 Tesla Model Y
$30,000 $4,615 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $4,615 (13.3%) under our fair value of $34,615 for its year, trim and mileage, with 47,212 miles, 4,481 above the median for 2023 listings.
- Fair value
- $34,615
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#10
2022 Tesla Model Y
$27,894 $4,580 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $4,580 (14.1%) under our fair value of $32,474 for its year, trim and mileage, with 48,799 miles, 13,335 under the median for 2022 listings.
- Fair value
- $32,474
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#11
2022 Tesla Model Y
$28,670 $4,270 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $4,270 (13%) under our fair value of $32,940 for its year, trim and mileage, and 45,227 miles sit 16,907 under the median for 2022 listings.
- Fair value
- $32,940
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#12
2022 Tesla Model Y
$28,734 $4,228 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $4,228 (12.8%) under our fair value of $32,962 for its year, trim and mileage, with 44,987 miles, 17,147 under the median for 2022 listings.
- Fair value
- $32,962
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#13
2020 Tesla Model Y
$26,200 $4,156 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $4,156 (13.7%) under our fair value of $30,356 for its year, trim and mileage, the lowest price of the 15 ranked deals, with 38,148 miles against a 65,578-mile median for 2020 listings.
- Fair value
- $30,356
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#14
2023 Tesla Model Y
$27,399 $4,091 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $4,091 (13%) under our fair value of $31,490 for its year, trim and mileage. Its 72,514 miles are 29,783 above the median for 2023 listings, a factor that supports a lower price.
- Fair value
- $31,490
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#15
2022 Tesla Model Y
$27,200 $3,992 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $3,992 (12.8%) under our fair value of $31,192 for its year, trim and mileage, with 59,943 miles in line with the median for 2022 listings.
- Fair value
- $31,192
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
Unlock all 15 Tesla Model Y deals
The locked deals are up to $5,683 below fair value. Members get the VIN, dealer, listing link and a ready-to-send negotiation email for every deal.
30-day money-back guarantee · Cancel anytime
What a Model Y Performance costs by model year
Median asking price of the live listings for each model year. 2025 is the sweet spot: its median is 25% below 2026’s.
How asking prices have moved
The average asking price across every model year, month by month. Up 11.2% since Dec 2025, from $29,552 to $32,857.
Show the monthly numbers
| Month | Average asking price |
|---|---|
| Dec 2025 | $29,552 |
| Jan 2026 | $29,243 |
| Feb 2026 | $29,162 |
| Mar 2026 | $30,385 |
| Apr 2026 | $31,473 |
| May 2026 | $32,828 |
| Jun 2026 | $32,976 |
| Jul 2026 | $32,725 |
| Aug 2026 | $32,703 |
| Sep 2026 | $32,434 |
| Oct 2026 | $32,857 |
Our read on the Model Y Performance market
From our latest analysis of this car, on .
- Best value year
- 2022
- Supply
- High
- How prices are spread
- Across all Tesla Model Y listings, asking prices rose 1.8% over the last 3 months. Among this page's listings, the middle half of prices runs from $28,993 to $35,699, and prices step up from $27,355 for 2020 cars to $39,133 for 2024 cars. Listings last checked on October 1, 2026.
- How to buy one
- Target 2022 and 2023 cars, where there are 441 and 252 listings respectively, and look for mileage near the typical level for those years. The market is hot with a typical 35-day time to sell, so negotiate firmly only on cars that have sat longer or have had price cuts. Always get a pre-purchase inspection and service records before buying.
Model Y Performance for sale
The 12 newest of 1,018 live listings in our latest scan, with dealers' asking prices. See every Tesla Model Y for sale.
-
2020 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $24,399 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $27,721 -
2021 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $28,991 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $30,073 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $30,993 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $31,990 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $32,398 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $32,587 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $33,998 -
2023 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $34,382 -
2021 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $34,553 -
2023 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $34,671
Keep comparing
More Tesla models
-
Tesla Model 3
Performance
Median of 627 listings$29,399 -
Tesla Model X
Plaid
Median of 245 listings$63,147 -
Tesla Model S
Plaid
Median of 236 listings$60,573 -
Tesla Cybertruck
All-Wheel Drive
Median of 135 listings$77,075 -
Tesla Cybertruck
Cyberbeast
Median of 59 listings$90,199 -
Tesla Roadster
Median of 8 listings$90,030 -
Tesla Roadster
Sport
Median of 2 listings$87,662