Sign in Unlock deals
Unlock deals Sign in

133 live listingsUpdated

Cadillac XLR

2004–2009Convertible 137 listings across every Cadillac XLR
Cadillac XLR

15 deals foundBest first

The best XLR deals right now

Only listings we rate Great or Good make the list. Each is priced against our fair value for its year, trim and miles.

1 deal is open to everyone. 14 are locked, with the VIN, dealer, listing link and a negotiation email. A free account unlocks one a month.

  1. #1
    Top deal Great deal Live listing

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    64,485 mi · Omaha, NE · Dealer hidden

    $11,000 $6,318 below fair value Deal score 99

    Priced $6,318 (36.5%) under our fair value of $17,318 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 207 comparable listings. Its 64,485 miles sit in line with the median of the 40 model-year 2004 listings.

    Fair value
    $17,318
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
  2. #2
    Great deal Live listing

    2006 Cadillac XLR

    68,896 mi · Elk River, MN · Greenlight Automotive

    $19,999 $8,380 below fair value Deal score 97

    Priced $8,380 (29.5%) under our fair value of $28,379 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 238 comparable listings. Its 68,896 miles are 17,331 more than the median of the 35 model-year 2006 listings.

    Fair value
    $28,379
    From 238 similar cars
    Open at
    $19,400
    3% under the ask
    Days listed
    19
    Typical: 158

    Free look: every member deal comes with these details

    VIN 1G6YX36D565602448

    View listing
  3. #3
    Great deal Live listing

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    61,278 mi · Sioux City, IA · Dealer hidden

    $12,950 $4,786 below fair value Deal score 96

    Priced $4,786 (27%) under our fair value of $17,736 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 207 comparable listings. Its 61,278 miles are close to the median of the 40 model-year 2004 listings.

    Fair value
    $17,736
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
  4. #4
    Great deal Live listing

    2005 Cadillac XLR

    97,246 mi · Attleboro, MA · Dealer hidden

    $10,995 $4,155 below fair value Deal score 96

    Priced $4,155 (27.4%) under our fair value of $15,150 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 221 comparable listings. Its 97,246 miles are 33,454 more than the median of the 31 model-year 2005 listings.

    Fair value
    $15,150
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
  5. #5
    Great deal Live listing

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    40,797 mi · Indianapolis, IN · Dealer hidden

    $15,999 $5,035 below fair value Deal score 94

    Priced $5,035 (23.9%) under our fair value of $21,034 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 207 comparable listings. Its 40,797 miles are 23,589 below the median of the 40 model-year 2004 listings, and the price has already been cut once.

    Fair value
    $21,034
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
  6. #6
    Great deal Live listing

    2008 Cadillac XLR

    12,500 mi · Omaha, NE · Dealer hidden

    $31,100 $9,464 below fair value Deal score 92

    Priced $9,464 (23.3%) under our fair value of $40,564 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 83 comparable listings. Its 12,500 miles are 61,019 below the median of the 9 model-year 2008 listings, the lowest mileage of the 15 ranked deals.

    Fair value
    $40,564
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
  7. #7
    Great deal Live listing

    2006 Cadillac XLR

    53,812 mi · Englewood, CO · Dealer hidden

    $14,995 $4,182 below fair value Deal score 92

    Priced $4,182 (21.8%) under our fair value of $19,177 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 238 comparable listings. Its 53,812 miles are in line with the median of the 35 model-year 2006 listings, and the price has been cut once.

    Fair value
    $19,177
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
  8. #8
    Great deal Live listing

    2007 Cadillac XLR

    47,786 mi · Lincolnwood, IL · Dealer hidden

    $18,936 $5,243 below fair value Deal score 91

    Priced $5,243 (21.7%) under our fair value of $24,179 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 12 comparable listings. Its 47,786 miles are 11,785 below the median of the 17 model-year 2007 listings.

    Fair value
    $24,179
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
  9. #9
    Great deal Live listing

    2008 Cadillac XLR

    79,700 mi · Mesa, AZ · Dealer hidden

    $15,999 $4,496 below fair value Deal score 91

    Priced $4,496 (21.9%) under our fair value of $20,495 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 83 comparable listings. Its 79,700 miles are 6,181 above the median of the 9 model-year 2008 listings.

    Fair value
    $20,495
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
  10. #10
    Great deal Live listing

    2005 Cadillac XLR

    67,730 mi · Phoenix, AZ · Dealer hidden

    $14,450 $3,639 below fair value Deal score 90

    Priced $3,639 (20.1%) under our fair value of $18,089 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 221 comparable listings. Its 67,730 miles are 3,938 above the median of the 31 model-year 2005 listings.

    Fair value
    $18,089
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
  11. #11
    Great deal Live listing

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    30,285 mi · St Charles, IL · Dealer hidden

    $19,999 $5,016 below fair value Deal score 89

    Priced $5,016 (20.1%) under our fair value of $25,015 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 207 comparable listings. Its 30,285 miles are 34,101 below the median of the 40 model-year 2004 listings.

    Fair value
    $25,015
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
  12. #12
    Great deal Live listing

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    64,515 mi · Duluth, GA · Dealer hidden

    $12,952 $3,058 below fair value Deal score 88

    Priced $3,058 (19.1%) under our fair value of $16,010 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 207 comparable listings. Its 64,515 miles are in line with the median of the 40 model-year 2004 listings.

    Fair value
    $16,010
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
  13. #13
    Great deal Live listing

    2005 Cadillac XLR

    101,780 mi · Portland, OR · Dealer hidden

    $11,995 $2,795 below fair value Deal score 88

    Priced $2,795 (18.9%) under our fair value of $14,790 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 221 comparable listings. Its 101,780 miles are 37,988 more than the median of the 31 model-year 2005 listings.

    Fair value
    $14,790
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
  14. #14
    Great deal Live listing

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    119,329 mi · Whitehall, OH · Dealer hidden

    $10,398 $2,361 below fair value Deal score 87

    Priced $2,361 (18.5%) under our fair value of $12,759 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 207 comparable listings. Its 119,329 miles are 54,943 more than the median of the 40 model-year 2004 listings, and it is the lowest price of the 15 ranked deals.

    Fair value
    $12,759
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
  15. #15
    Good deal Live listing

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    20,623 mi · Bloomingdale, NJ · Dealer hidden

    $22,488 $4,304 below fair value Deal score 84

    Priced $4,304 (16.1%) under our fair value of $26,792 for its year, trim and mileage, based on 207 comparable listings. Its 20,623 miles are 43,763 below the median of the 40 model-year 2004 listings.

    Fair value
    $26,792
    Open at
    Hidden
    Days listed
    Hidden
    The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden

Unlock all 15 Cadillac XLR deals

The locked deals are up to $9,464 below fair value. Members get the VIN, dealer, listing link and a ready-to-send negotiation email for every deal.

30-day money-back guarantee · Cancel anytime

What a XLR costs by model year

Median asking price of the live listings for each model year. 2007 is the sweet spot: its median is 10% below 2008’s.

  1. 2009 $40,371 1 listing · 69,000 mi median
  2. 2008 $23,995 9 listings · 73,519 mi median
  3. 2007Sweet spot $21,521 17 listings · 59,571 mi median
  4. 2006 $20,897 35 listings · 51,565 mi median
  5. 2005 $19,000 31 listings · 63,792 mi median
  6. 2004 $17,650 40 listings · 64,386 mi median

Cadillac XLR price guide: fair value by year and trim

How asking prices have moved

The average asking price across every model year, month by month. Up 7.2% since Nov 2025, from $20,537 to $22,015.

Show the monthly numbers
MonthAverage asking price
Nov 2025$20,537
May 2026$19,933
Nov 2026$22,015

Our read on the XLR market

From our latest analysis of this car, on .

Best value year
2004
Supply
High
How prices are spread
Across all Cadillac XLR listings, asking prices rose 2.6% over the last 12 months. The middle half of this vehicle's prices sits between $15,813 and $25,339, and the 2004 and 2005 model years have the lowest median prices at $17,650 and $19,000.
How to buy one
Target 2004 to 2005 cars with mileage near the median for their year, since those offer the most value across 74 listings. The market is warm and these cars take a long time to sell, so relisted and price-cut cars give you leverage. Before buying, arrange a pre-purchase inspection and a vehicle history report.

XLR for sale

The 12 newest of 133 live listings in our latest scan, with dealers' asking prices. See every Cadillac XLR for sale.

  • 44,263 mi · Orlando, FL

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    Asking price $18,850

  • 57,658 mi · Naples, FL

    2006 Cadillac XLR

    Star Black Limited Edition

    Asking price $18,991

  • 20,821 mi · Albert Lea, MN

    2005 Cadillac XLR

    Asking price $25,999

  • 72,940 mi · Watertown, WI

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    Asking price $17,995

  • 42,394 mi · Cathedral City, CA

    2007 Cadillac XLR

    Passion Red Limited Edition

    Asking price $23,940

  • 42,331 mi · Uniontown, PA

    2005 Cadillac XLR

    Asking price $25,900

  • 61,278 mi · Sioux City, IA

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    Asking price $12,950

  • 60,219 mi · Fort Walton Beach, FL

    2007 Cadillac XLR

    Passion Red Limited Edition

    Asking price $20,990

  • 27,330 mi · Sylvania, OH

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    Asking price $30,397

  • 86,787 mi · Houston, TX

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    Asking price $13,817

  • 53,153 mi · O'Fallon, IL

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    Asking price $31,000

  • 64,485 mi · Omaha, NE

    2004 Cadillac XLR

    Asking price $11,000

Keep comparing

More Cadillac models

Every Cadillac for sale

Prices are dealers' asking prices from the listings we track. Deals and our read come from our analysis of this car on Nov 1, 2026.