15 live listingsUpdated
Used BMW M5 for sale in New York
We're tracking 15 used BMW M5s for sale in New York right now, priced from $14,999 to $170,174 with a median asking price of $71,165. Model years range from 2008 to 2023, the typical car shows 44,098 mi, and half are priced between $56,170 and $100,123.
That's 5% of the 283 used BMW M5s we track nationwide. The most are listed in Staten Island (3), Yonkers (3), and Amityville (2). Comparing the same model, year and trim, the typical BMW M5 here is listed 8% above similar cars elsewhere in the US (15 cars compared).
The lowest-priced one is a 2008 BMW M5 Base listed at $14,999 with 138,616 mi in Mahopac, NY.
Best BMW M5 deals in New York
2 deals priced below market right now, the best by about $10,501. Members get the VIN, dealer, listing link and a ready-to-send negotiation email for each one.
-
$11k below market Locked2023 BMW M5
F90
Great deal: about $11k under fair value for its year, trim and miles.
Asking price $85,942Deal score 92 -
$6k below market Locked2023 BMW M5
F90
Good deal: about $6k under fair value for its year, trim and miles.
Asking price $86,170Deal score 80
Members see every deal's VIN, dealer and listing link, plus a negotiation email.
Latest used BMW M5s in New York
-
2021 BMW M5
F90
Asking price $50,170 -
2019 BMW M5
F90
Asking price $68,500 -
2023 BMW M5
F90
Asking price $71,165 -
2018 BMW M5
F90
Asking price $62,170 -
2008 BMW M5
E60
Asking price $37,000 -
2018 BMW M5
F90
Asking price $46,425 -
2019 BMW M5
F90
Asking price $62,925 -
2023 BMW M5
F90
Asking price $85,942 -
2022 BMW M5
F90
Asking price $120,174 -
2008 BMW M5
E60
Asking price $14,999 -
2023 BMW M5
F90
Asking price $100,170 -
2022 BMW M5
F90 CS
Asking price $170,174 -
2022 BMW M5
F90 CS
Asking price $155,174 -
2023 BMW M5
F90
Asking price $86,170 -
2021 BMW M5
F90
Asking price $100,075
BMW M5 prices by model year in New York
Median asking price for each model year among the BMW M5s for sale in New York.
- 2023 $86,056
- 2022 $155,174
- 2021 $75,123
- 2019 $65,713
- 2018 $54,298
- 2008 $26,000
New York vs. the rest of the US
Comparing the same model, year and trim, the typical BMW M5 here is listed 8% above similar cars elsewhere. The medians below also reflect which years and trims are listed in each place.
| Location | For sale | Median price | Lowest price | Median miles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York | 15 | $71,165 | $14,999 | 44,098 |
| Rest of the US | 268 | $50,007 | $14,900 | 64,972 |
Where in New York BMW M5s are for sale
| City | For sale | Median price | Lowest price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Staten Island | 3 | $155,174 | $120,174 |
| Yonkers | 3 | $62,170 | $46,425 |
| Amityville | 2 | $93,170 | $86,170 |
| Brooklyn | 2 | $54,083 | $37,000 |
| Farmingdale | 1 | $100,075 | $100,075 |
| Great Neck | 1 | $50,170 | $50,170 |
| Mahopac | 1 | $14,999 | $14,999 |
| Rochester | 1 | $85,942 | $85,942 |
| Watervliet | 1 | $68,500 | $68,500 |
Used BMW M5s in other states
- Used BMW M5s in Arizona5
- Used BMW M5s in California38
- Used BMW M5s in Colorado7
- Used BMW M5s in Connecticut8
- Used BMW M5s in Florida30
- Used BMW M5s in Georgia11
- Used BMW M5s in Illinois24
- Used BMW M5s in Indiana6
- Used BMW M5s in Michigan5
- Used BMW M5s in New Jersey13
- Used BMW M5s in North Carolina13
- Used BMW M5s in Oregon9
- Used BMW M5s in Pennsylvania7
- Used BMW M5s in Texas19
- Used BMW M5s in Virginia17
- Used BMW M5s in Washington15
Used BMW M5s in New York: common questions
How much does a used BMW M5 cost in New York?
Used BMW M5 asking prices in New York currently range from $14,999 to $170,174, with a median of $71,165 across 15 listings. Half of them are priced between $56,170 and $100,123.
Are used BMW M5s cheaper in New York?
No. Comparing the same model, year and trim, used BMW M5s in New York are listed a median 8% above similar cars elsewhere in the US, across 15 cars with matches. Mileage, options and condition still vary from car to car.
Where in New York are the most used BMW M5s for sale?
Staten Island (3), Yonkers (3), Amityville (2), Brooklyn (2), and Farmingdale (1) have the most listings in our latest scan.
What is the cheapest BMW M5 for sale right now in New York?
The lowest asking price in our latest scan is a 2008 BMW M5 Base listed at $14,999 with 138,616 mi in Mahopac, NY.
Which BMW M5 model years are for sale in New York?
Listings span 2008 to 2023. The 2023 model year has the most cars for sale (4, median $86,056). The newest 2023 cars have a median asking price of $86,056, versus $26,000 for 2008.
How many miles do used BMW M5s for sale in New York have?
The median BMW M5 for sale in New York shows 44,098 mi. 5 of 15 listings (33%) have under 15,000 miles.
How long do BMW M5s stay on the market in New York?
Current BMW M5 listings in New York have been for sale for a median of 57 days. Cars that sit well beyond that are often the easiest to negotiate on.
How current is this data?
These numbers come from our latest scan of dealer listings on Oct 1, 2026. Luxury Car Deals rescans the market regularly and removes cars that have sold.