6 live listingsUpdated
Used luxury and exotic cars for sale in Bay Shore, NY
We're tracking 6 used luxury cars for sale in Bay Shore, NY right now, priced from $26,163 to $71,400 with a median asking price of $45,220. Model years range from 2018 to 2025 and the typical car shows 16,529 mi.
That's 0% of the 25,942 used luxury cars we track nationwide. Comparing the same model, year and trim, the typical luxury car here is listed 4% below similar cars elsewhere in the US (6 cars compared).
The lowest-priced one is a 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance listed at $26,163 with 96,446 mi in Bay Shore, NY.
Best luxury car deals in Bay Shore, NY
1 deal priced below market right now, the best by about $1,248. Members get the VIN, dealer, listing link and a ready-to-send negotiation email for each one.
Members see every deal's VIN, dealer and listing link, plus a negotiation email.
Latest used luxury cars in Bay Shore, NY
-
2023 Chevrolet Corvette
C8 Stingray
Asking price $71,400 -
2023 Chevrolet Corvette
C8 Stingray
Asking price $64,209 -
2018 BMW 7 Series
G11 740i xDrive
Asking price $39,990 -
2021 BMW 7 Series
G11 Facelift 750i xDrive
Asking price $29,995 -
2025 Ford Mustang
7th Gen GT Premium
Asking price $50,450 -
2022 Tesla Model Y
Performance
Asking price $26,163
Bay Shore, NY vs. the rest of the US
Comparing the same model, year and trim, the typical luxury car here is listed 4% below similar cars elsewhere. The medians below also reflect which years and trims are listed in each place.
| Location | For sale | Median price | Lowest price | Median miles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bay Shore, NY | 6 | $45,220 | $26,163 | 16,529 |
| Rest of the US | 25,936 | $75,874 | $2,849 | 23,603 |
Other New York cities
- Used luxury cars in Staten Island, NY68
- Used luxury cars in Glen Cove, NY43
- Used luxury cars in Plainview, NY33
- Used luxury cars in Yonkers, NY30
- Used luxury cars in Freeport, NY28
- Used luxury cars in Roslyn, NY27
- Used luxury cars in Farmingdale, NY24
- Used luxury cars in Great Neck, NY24
- Used luxury cars in Brooklyn, NY22
- Used luxury cars in Bayside, NY17
- Used luxury cars in Amityville, NY16
- Used luxury cars in Buffalo, NY15
- Used luxury cars in Cortland, NY13
- Used luxury cars in New York, NY13
- Used luxury cars in Bronx, NY12
- Used luxury cars in Huntington Station, NY11
- Used luxury cars in Albany, NY9
- Used luxury cars in Long Island City, NY9
- Used luxury cars in New Rochelle, NY9
- Used luxury cars in Valley Stream, NY8
- Used luxury cars in Westbury, NY8
- Used luxury cars in Franklin Square, NY7
- Used luxury cars in Hauppauge, NY7
- Used luxury cars in Rochester, NY7
- Used luxury cars in Forest Hills, NY6
- Used luxury cars in Huntington, NY6
- Used luxury cars in Inwood, NY6
- Used luxury cars in Avon, NY5
- Used luxury cars in Hamburg, NY5
- Used luxury cars in Jackson Heights, NY5
- Used luxury cars in Medford, NY5
- Used luxury cars in New Hyde Park, NY5
- Used luxury cars in Syracuse, NY5
Used luxury cars in Bay Shore, NY: common questions
How much does a used luxury car cost in Bay Shore, NY?
Used luxury car asking prices in Bay Shore, NY currently range from $26,163 to $71,400, with a median of $45,220 across 6 listings.
Are used luxury cars cheaper in Bay Shore, NY?
Slightly. Comparing the same model, year and trim, used luxury cars in Bay Shore, NY are listed a median 4% below similar cars elsewhere in the US, across 6 cars with matches. Mileage, options and condition still vary from car to car.
Which brands are for sale in Bay Shore, NY?
The most listed are BMW (2 cars, median $34,993), Chevrolet (2 cars, median $67,805), Ford (1 car, median $50,450), and Tesla (1 car, median $26,163).
What is the cheapest luxury car for sale right now in Bay Shore, NY?
The lowest asking price in our latest scan is a 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance listed at $26,163 with 96,446 mi in Bay Shore, NY.
How many miles do used luxury cars for sale in Bay Shore, NY have?
The median luxury car for sale in Bay Shore, NY shows 16,529 mi. 3 of 6 listings (50%) have under 15,000 miles.
How long do luxury cars stay on the market in Bay Shore, NY?
Current luxury car listings in Bay Shore, NY have been for sale for a median of 39 days. Cars that sit well beyond that are often the easiest to negotiate on.
How current is this data?
These numbers come from our latest scan of dealer listings on Nov 1, 2026. Luxury Car Deals rescans the market regularly and removes cars that have sold.