Compare prices within the same model year
2011
The market for enthusiast vehicles like the BMW M3 is generally stable to appreciating, especially for well-maintained examples. While specific trends require deeper historical data, current listings suggest a healthy availability with a wide spectrum of pricing based on condition, mileage, and specific options.
Moderate
The BMW M3 market shows significant price variation, with a wide range from $15,989 to $249,490. Buyers seeking the best value should focus on models from 2011, which appear to offer a strong balance of performance, condition, and price point, often with lower mileage than older counterparts. Given the average mileage is around 71,000 miles, vehicles with significantly lower mileage, like those under 45,000 miles, represent excellent opportunities. Be prepared for potentially longer negotiation times on some listings, as indicated by the average days on market, but don't be deterred if a vehicle has been listed longer, as it may present a better negotiation opportunity.
This deal stands out with a high deal score, significantly lower mileage than average (32,999 vs 71,082), and substantial estimated savings. Despite a longer days on market, the combination of a desirable 2013 model year and excellent condition makes it a top pick.
This 2011 M3 offers a great combination of low mileage (38,244) and a strong deal score. The estimated savings are substantial, and while it has been on the market for 210 days, its overall value proposition is excellent.
This 2011 M3 is a standout deal due to its exceptional estimated savings ($12,096) and relatively low mileage (44,947). The long days on market (348) could indicate room for negotiation, making it a prime candidate for a savvy buyer.
This 2011 M3 offers a very attractive mileage of 34,165, well below the average, combined with a solid deal score. The estimated savings are notable, and its presence on the market for 165 days suggests a good opportunity for negotiation.
This 2013 M3 is a top-tier find with an incredibly low 23,000 miles and the highest estimated savings ($14,013) among the top deals. Its strong deal score and relatively short time on market (67 days) make it an exceptional opportunity.
This 2013 M3 is remarkable for its extremely low mileage (19,321 miles), making it one of the lowest available. Combined with a good deal score and estimated savings, it represents excellent value for a nearly new example.
This 2013 M3 offers the highest estimated savings ($15,010) in the top deals, coupled with a respectable 39,831 miles. Its strong deal score and moderate time on market (89 days) make it a very attractive purchase.
This 2008 M3 is a more budget-friendly option, offering a lower entry price point. While mileage is higher at 82,590, its deal score is solid, and the 138 days on market might present negotiation leverage.
This 2010 M3 offers a good balance with 61,497 miles and a respectable deal score. It has been on the market for a relatively short time (43 days), indicating good interest, but still presents an opportunity for savings.
This 2008 M3 is priced very competitively, with minimal estimated savings but a reasonable price for its mileage (75,909). The 100 days on market suggests potential for negotiation on this older model.
This 2009 M3 has a good mileage of 61,580 and a decent deal score. The estimated savings are minimal, but the 136 days on market indicates it might be a good candidate for negotiation.
This 2008 M3 is priced attractively for its age, and the estimated savings are decent. The extremely long days on market (519) is a strong indicator that there is significant room for negotiation, making it a potential bargain if mileage is not a primary concern.
This 2008 M3 offers a competitive price for its mileage (90,569) and a reasonable deal score. The 92 days on market suggest it's been available for a while, potentially opening the door for negotiation.
This 2011 M3 presents a substantial estimated savings of $11,101, making it a strong value proposition despite its mileage of 79,531. The 88 days on market suggest it's a good candidate for negotiation.
This 2013 M3 offers a great combination of relatively low mileage (41,166) and significant estimated savings ($10,011). Despite being on the market for a short period (18 days), its strong deal score and value make it worth pursuing.
Last analyzed: February 1, 2026