Sign in Unlock deals
Unlock deals Sign in

120 live listingsUpdated

Ferrari 458 Italia vs 488 GTB: used prices and resale value, side by side

A used Ferrari 458 Italia asks a median of $359,000 in our latest scan, 13% more than a Ferrari 488 GTB at $317,197.

There are 49 458 Italias for sale from model years 2010-2015 and 71 488 GTBs from 2016-2019. Asking prices come from 120 live dealer listings in our latest scan; value kept compares model years with the same trim and miles in our market model.

458 Italia and 488 GTB at a glance

The short answer

Who wins on each measure. Close calls (within a few percent) say either.

If you want Pick Why
The lower price 488 GTB Median asking price $317,197, 12% below the 458 Italia's $359,000
More to choose from 488 GTB 71 for sale, against 49 458 Italias
A quicker sale when you sell 458 Italia A typical one leaves the market in about 50 days, against 63 for the 488 GTB
The cheapest one for sale 458 Italia A 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia listed at $195,889 with 36,188 mi in Hamilton Township, NJ

Every number, head to head

458 Italia 488 GTB
For sale now 49 71
Median asking price $359,000 $317,197
Middle half of asking prices $326k to $400k $294k to $350k
Cheapest for sale $195,889 $220,249
Median miles 19,703 mi 12,290 mi
Model years for sale 2010-2015 2016-2019
Value kept after 3 years – –
Value kept after 5 years – –
Priced below market now 7 (14%) 12 (17%)
Typical days to sell 50 63

Asking prices by model year

Median asking price and listings for each model year in our latest scan, newest first.

Model year 458 Italia median 458 Italia for sale 488 GTB median 488 GTB for sale
2019 – – $355,985 12
2018 – – $319,685 26
2017 – – $309,888 18
2016 – – $297,212 15
2015 $426,125 5 – –
2014 $343,581 9 – –
2013 $359,893 4 – –
2012 $359,000 7 – –
2011 $322,288 10 – –
2010 $375,720 14 – –

The cheapest 458 Italia and 488 GTB for sale

The 3 lowest asking prices of each in our latest scan of dealer listings.

458 Italia and 488 GTB priced below market

19 deals priced below market right now, the best by about $129,882. Members get the VIN, dealer, listing link and a ready-to-send negotiation email for each one.

Unlock all 19 deals

Members see every deal's VIN, dealer and listing link, plus a negotiation email.

Ferrari 458 Italia vs 488 GTB: common questions

Which is cheaper used, the Ferrari 458 Italia or the Ferrari 488 GTB?

The 488 GTB: its median asking price is $317,197, against $359,000 for the 458 Italia in our scan of Oct 1, 2026. The cheapest 458 Italia is a 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia listed at $195,889 with 36,188 mi in Hamilton Township, NJ. The cheapest 488 GTB is a 2018 Ferrari 488 GTB listed at $220,249 with 14,076 mi in Pompano Beach, FL.

How many 458 Italias and 488 GTBs are for sale?

There are 49 458 Italias for sale from model years 2010-2015 and 71 488 GTBs from 2016-2019. That's from our latest scan of US dealer listings.

Which sells faster, the Ferrari 458 Italia or the Ferrari 488 GTB?

The 458 Italia: a typical one leaves the market in about 50 days, against 63 days.

Where do these numbers come from?

Prices are live asking prices from US dealer listings in our latest scan, not sale prices. Value kept and days to sell come from our market model, which compares the same trims and miles across model years.