49 live listingsUpdated
Ferrari 458 Italia
7 deals foundBest first
The best 458 Italia deals right now
Only listings we rate Great or Good make the list. Each is priced against our fair value for its year, trim and miles. Last checked 21 days ago, so some may have sold.
1 deal is open to everyone. 6 are locked, with the VIN, dealer, listing link and a negotiation email. A free account unlocks one a month.
-
#1
2014 Ferrari 458 Italia
$330,497 $129,882 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $129,882 (28.2%) under our fair value of $460,379 for its year, trim and mileage, and the lowest-mileage-to-price gap among the ranked deals is not the point here; it is the largest discount we track in this group, with 8,439 fewer miles than the median of the 9 model-year 2014 listings.
- Fair value
- $460,379
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#2
2010 Ferrari 458 Italia
$276,581 $104,953 below fair value Deal score 100Priced $104,953 (27.5%) under our fair value of $381,534 for its year, trim and mileage, with 5,312 fewer miles than the median of the 14 model-year 2010 listings.
- Fair value
- $381,534
- From 99 similar cars
- Open at
- $265,600
- 4% under the ask
- Aim to pay
- $273,815
- Days listed
- 39
- Typical: 50
Some room to negotiate.
Free look: every member deal comes with these details
VIN ZFF67NFA5A0175348
-
#3
2013 Ferrari 458 Italia
$340,790 $35,528 below fair value Deal score 82Priced $35,528 (9.4%) under our fair value of $376,318 for its year, trim and mileage, and in line with the median mileage of the 4 model-year 2013 listings.
- Fair value
- $376,318
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#4
2014 Ferrari 458 Italia
$479,995 $44,241 below fair value Deal score 79Priced $44,241 (8.4%) under our fair value of $524,236 for its year, trim and mileage, with 11,956 fewer miles than the median of the 9 model-year 2014 listings.
- Fair value
- $524,236
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#5
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia
$259,990 $20,587 below fair value Deal score 76Priced $20,587 (7.3%) under our fair value of $280,577 for its year, trim and mileage, and the lowest price of the 7 ranked deals.
- Fair value
- $280,577
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#6
2010 Ferrari 458 Italia
$470,489 $38,908 below fair value Deal score 75Priced $38,908 (7.6%) under our fair value of $509,397 for its year, trim and mileage, with 15,740 fewer miles than the median of the 14 model-year 2010 listings and the lowest mileage of the 7 ranked deals.
- Fair value
- $509,397
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden -
#7
2014 Ferrari 458 Italia
$343,581 $23,079 below fair value Deal score 72Priced $23,079 (6.3%) under our fair value of $366,660 for its year, trim and mileage, though 4,059 miles above the median of the 9 model-year 2014 listings.
- Fair value
- $366,660
- Open at
- Hidden
- Days listed
- Hidden
The VIN, dealer and listing link are hidden
Unlock all 7 Ferrari 458 Italia deals
The locked deals are up to $129,882 below fair value. Members get the VIN, dealer, listing link and a ready-to-send negotiation email for every deal.
30-day money-back guarantee · Cancel anytime
What a 458 Italia costs by model year
Median asking price of the live listings for each model year. 2014 is the sweet spot: its median is 19% below 2015’s.
How asking prices have moved
The average asking price across every model year, month by month. Up 78.5% since Oct 2025, from $215,355 to $384,516.
Show the monthly numbers
| Month | Average asking price |
|---|---|
| Oct 2025 | $215,355 |
| Nov 2025 | $214,534 |
| Dec 2025 | $228,528 |
| Jan 2026 | $236,948 |
| Feb 2026 | $233,148 |
| Mar 2026 | $232,190 |
| Apr 2026 | $233,941 |
| May 2026 | $250,826 |
| Jun 2026 | $304,666 |
| Aug 2026 | $419,585 |
| Sep 2026 | $411,526 |
| Oct 2026 | $384,516 |
Our read on the 458 Italia market
From our latest analysis of this car, on .
- Best value year
- 2011
- Supply
- High
- How prices are spread
- The middle half of this model's asking prices runs from $326,130 to $399,990, with a median of $359,000. Median prices step from $375,720 for 2010 cars to $322,288 for 2011, then rise to $426,125 for 2015. Listings last checked on October 1, 2026.
- How to buy one
- Target 2010 to 2012 cars with mileage near the median of about 19,703 miles, where the best deals cluster. The market is balanced, with a typical time to sell of 50 days and 4.1 months of supply, so a patient offer that waits for a long-listed car can pay off. Arrange a pre-purchase inspection and a vehicle history report before committing.
458 Italia for sale
The 12 newest of 49 live listings in our latest scan, with dealers' asking prices. See every Ferrari 458 Italia for sale.
-
2014 Ferrari 458 Italia
Asking price $336,075 -
2012 Ferrari 458 Italia
Asking price $289,900 -
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia
Asking price $289,900 -
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia
Asking price $339,900 -
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia
Asking price $599,999 -
2010 Ferrari 458 Italia
Asking price $470,489 -
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia
Asking price $350,113 -
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia
Asking price $380,113 -
2013 Ferrari 458 Italia
Asking price $449,995 -
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia
Asking price $529,999 -
2010 Ferrari 458 Italia
Asking price $250,575 -
2010 Ferrari 458 Italia
Asking price $276,581
Keep comparing
More Ferrari models
-
Ferrari 488 Spider
Median of 122 listings$397,023 -
Ferrari 296 GTS
Median of 74 listings$440,000 -
Ferrari 488 GTB
Median of 71 listings$317,197 -
Ferrari F8 Spider
Median of 70 listings$647,979 -
Ferrari F8 Tributo
Median of 67 listings$465,900 -
Ferrari 296 GTB
Median of 66 listings$349,999 -
Ferrari 812 GTS
Median of 63 listings$853,679 -
Ferrari California
Median of 52 listings$98,110