Ferrari 458 Italia
Average Price by Year
Compare prices within the same model year
Market Insights
Best Value Year
2013
Price Trend
The market for the Ferrari 458 Italia appears stable, with a wide price range reflecting variations in year, mileage, and condition. While the average price is substantial, significant savings are achievable, particularly on listings with higher mileage or longer days on market. Negotiation is a critical component of securing a favorable deal.
Inventory Level
Low
Buyer Advice
The Ferrari 458 Italia market currently presents a diverse range of options, with a significant spread in pricing and mileage. While inventory is relatively low, there are compelling opportunities for savvy buyers. Patience and thorough research are key; consider vehicles that have been on the market longer, as they may offer more negotiation leverage. Focus on the overall condition and maintenance history, as these factors can significantly impact long-term ownership costs for a supercar.
Top 11 Recommended Deals
This deal is highly recommended due to its top ranking, excellent deal score, and significantly lower mileage (13,207) compared to the market average. It represents a strong value proposition for a well-maintained 2013 model.
This listing ranks second with a solid deal score and mileage (22,500) that is close to the market average. It offers a good balance of performance and value for a 2011 model.
This deal is notable for its substantial estimated savings of over $31,000, making it one of the best values on the list. While it has higher mileage (37,627), the price point for this 2010 model is very attractive.
This 2014 model is a strong contender, offering a more recent year with 35,200 miles. Its longer days on market (216) suggest potential for negotiation, making it a good value despite lower estimated savings.
This 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia is a solid choice with 38,947 miles. It has been on the market for 44 days, indicating steady interest, and offers a good balance of age and mileage for its price point.
This 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia offers a great combination of relatively low mileage (25,429) and substantial estimated savings of nearly $30,000. Its presence on the market for 22 days suggests it's a fresh listing with good potential.
This 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia stands out due to its exceptionally high estimated savings of over $47,000. While it has higher mileage (65,513), the aggressive pricing makes it a compelling option for buyers prioritizing value over lower mileage.
This 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia offers a great balance with 29,300 miles and substantial estimated savings of over $45,000. It has been on the market for 21 days, indicating it's a relatively fresh listing with good value.
This 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia is a standout due to its very low mileage (16,776) and recent listing (6 days on market). While estimated savings are modest, its condition and desirability make it a prime candidate.
This 2015 Ferrari 458 Italia is the newest model listed, boasting extremely low mileage (11,196) and a very short time on market (7 days). It represents a premium option for those seeking a nearly new example.
This 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia is the most affordable option by a significant margin, offering the highest estimated savings ($72,224). It has the highest mileage (67,052) among the listed deals, making it a value-focused choice for those prioritizing price.
Unlock All Premium Deals
See the exact VINs, dealer contacts, and negotiation strategies that could save you $15,000+
Similar Cars You Might Like
Last analyzed: March 5, 2026