Ferrari 458 Italia
AI Analyzed

Ferrari 458 Italia

Overall Average Market Price
$419,585
Range: $260,075 - $1,349,973

Average Price by Year

Compare prices within the same model year

2010
$630,981
14,744 mi avg
4 listings
2011
$388,397
20,685 mi avg
5 listings
2012
$363,751
22,796 mi avg
8 listings
2013
$415,799
13,997 mi avg
1 listings
2014
$394,652
20,205 mi avg
6 listings
2015
$374,795
12,815 mi avg
2 listings
26
Active Listings
19,447
Overall Avg Mileage
65
Days on Market

Market Insights

Best Value Year

2012

Price Trend

The market for the Ferrari 458 Italia is characterized by a wide price spectrum, indicating that individual vehicle condition, mileage, and seller motivation play a significant role. While the average price is around $420,000, there are substantial opportunities for savings, suggesting a competitive environment where negotiation is expected and often rewarded.

Inventory Level

Low

Buyer Advice

The Ferrari 458 Italia market shows significant price variation, offering opportunities for astute buyers. With a limited total inventory, patience and thorough research are key. Focus on vehicles with lower mileage and consider those that have been on the market longer, as they may present better negotiation leverage. Always be prepared to make a well-researched offer.

Top 15 Recommended Deals

Best Deal
#1
Deal 1
2015 $369,000
Save ~$5,795
7,354 mi Nebraska City, NE 2015
Henry Motors South
Deal Score: 96%

This deal stands out due to its exceptionally low mileage for a 458 Italia, combined with a competitive price point that offers a modest but positive estimated saving. It represents a well-preserved example of the model.

VIN: ZFF67NFA2F0209737
View Listing
#2
Deal 2
2012 $299,900
Save ~$63,851
19,477 mi Orlando, FL 2012
Exotic Knights
Deal Score: 86%

This listing offers one of the most substantial estimated savings in the market, making it a standout deal. The mileage is right around the average, suggesting a well-used but not excessively driven example at a compelling price.

VIN: ZFF67NFA6C0183171
View Listing
#3
Deal 3
2010 $398,580
Save ~$232,401
7,028 mi Salt Lake City, UT 2010
Ferrari of Salt Lake City
Deal Score: 78%

This deal is highly recommended due to its extremely low mileage and a significant estimated saving, indicating it's priced very competitively for its condition. The short days on market suggest strong interest, but the savings potential is substantial.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7A0176050
View Listing
#4
Deal 4
2014 $335,799
Save ~$58,853
21,969 mi Wilmington, NC 2014
Stevenson-Hendrick Mazda Wilmington
Deal Score: 73%

This listing offers a good balance of a relatively recent model year, mileage slightly above average but still reasonable, and a significant estimated saving, making it an attractive proposition.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7E0201518
View Listing
#5
Deal 5
2012 $305,799
Save ~$57,952
22,031 mi Wilmington, NC 2012
Stevenson-Hendrick Mazda Wilmington
Deal Score: 68%

This deal is notable for its substantial estimated savings and a price point that is very attractive for a 458 Italia. The mileage is around average, and its presence on the market for only 10 days suggests it's a popular listing.

VIN: ZFF67NFA5C0184750
View Listing
#6
Deal 6
2010 $375,382
Save ~$255,599
16,976 mi Akron, OH 2010
Perfect Auto Collection
Deal Score: 59%

This listing presents an outstanding opportunity with one of the highest estimated savings available, coupled with mileage well below the average. It's a compelling deal for a 2010 model.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7A0175884
View Listing
#7
Deal 7
2014 $389,999
Save ~$4,653
16,534 mi Costa Mesa, CA 2014
Eurocar
Deal Score: 54%

This deal is recommended for its low mileage and relatively recent model year, offering a good balance of performance and condition. While the estimated savings are modest, the overall package is strong.

VIN: ZFF67NFA9E0196855
View Listing
#8
Deal 8
2011 $334,900
Save ~$53,497
25,838 mi North Charlotte, NC 2011
Tactical Fleet Charlotte
Deal Score: 49%

This listing offers a solid estimated saving and a price point that is competitive for a 2011 model. The mileage is slightly above average but still within a reasonable range for this supercar.

VIN: ZFF67NFA3B0180775
View Listing
#9
Deal 9
2012 $309,900
Save ~$53,851
36,636 mi Dallas, TX 2012
Tactical Fleet
Deal Score: 48%

This deal is attractive due to its significant estimated savings and a price point that is among the lower end for a 2012 model, despite having mileage above the average.

VIN: ZFF67NFA4C0186389
View Listing
#10
Deal 10
2012 $299,925
Save ~$63,826
37,029 mi Carrollton, TX 2012
Earth MotorCars
Deal Score: 46%

This listing offers a very attractive price point and a significant estimated saving, making it a strong contender, even with mileage that is above the average.

VIN: ZFF67NFA2C0183510
View Listing
#11
Deal 11
2011 $366,075
Save ~$22,322
22,954 mi Redwood City, CA 2011
Ferrari Silicon Valley
Deal Score: 43%

This deal is from a reputable Ferrari dealer and offers a 2011 model with mileage slightly above average, at a price that provides a moderate estimated saving.

VIN: ZFF67NFA1B0180581
View Listing
#12
Deal 12
2011 $260,075
Save ~$128,322
44,199 mi West Hollywood, CA 2011
Specialty Car Collection
Deal Score: 43%

This listing stands out for its very low price point and substantial estimated savings, making it the most affordable option among the top deals, despite having the highest mileage.

VIN: ZFF67NFA7B0176521
View Listing
#13
Deal 13
2014 $350,994
Save ~$43,658
30,147 mi Tampa, FL 2014
European Exotic Center
Deal Score: 42%

This deal offers a 2014 model with mileage above average but still reasonable, at a price that provides a decent estimated saving.

VIN: ZFF67NFA4E0197573
View Listing
#14
Deal 14
2010 $399,990
Save ~$230,991
30,392 mi Momence, IL 2010
Route 1 Chevrolet
Deal Score: 42%

This listing presents a significant estimated saving, making it a compelling deal, although the mileage is above average and it has been on the market for an extended period, suggesting potential for negotiation.

VIN: ZFF67NFA4A0175132
View Listing
#15
Deal 15
2014 $310,199
Save ~$84,453
35,543 mi Houston, TX 2014
Auto Vision LLC
Deal Score: 40%

This deal offers a good estimated saving and a price point that is attractive for a 2014 model, despite having mileage that is above the average.

VIN: ZFF67NFA3E0199055
View Listing
πŸ”’

Unlock All Premium Deals

See the exact VINs, dealer contacts, and negotiation strategies that could save you $15,000+

βœ“ Full dealer info
βœ“ Negotiation tips
βœ“ Price history
βœ“ Market alerts
Customer
"Found my Ferrari 488 for $22k below market using these exact deals!"
- Michael R.
Customer
"Saved $18,000 on my Lamborghini HuracΓ‘n. The AI found deals I never would have seen."
- Sarah K.
Customer
"Got my Porsche 911 GT3 for $35k under asking. This service pays for itself!"
- David L.
30-day money-back guarantee

Last analyzed: August 1, 2026