Ferrari 458 Italia price guide

It depends most on the model year and trim. Based on asking prices for comparable cars, our market model puts a 2015 458 Italia base model at about $427,000 with 11,200 miles, a 2013 at about $379,000 with 14,900 miles, and a 2010 at about $362,000 with 16,900 miles. The 49 for sale now ask $195,889 to $1,332,973.

With the same trim and miles, a 2012 is typically listed at about 95% of a 2015's price and a 2010 at about 93%. These come from today's asking prices across model years, so they show how the market prices age rather than one car's history.

Each extra 1,000 miles takes about $4,300 off the asking price of a typical Ferrari 458 Italia, at the same model year and trim.

The typical Ferrari 458 Italia leaves the market, sold or taken off sale, about 50 days after it's first listed. That's the median over the cars we saw go in the last six months. Right now our model rates 7 of the cars for sale as good or great deals.

Luxury Car Deals' market model compares 144 Ferrari 458 Italia listings over the past year and separates the effects of model year, trim, mileage and body style. Fair values are typical asking prices for comparable cars at the usual mileage for their model year, not sale prices; a specific car also moves with its options, color, history and condition. Asking prices are from our latest scan of dealer listings on Oct 1, 2026.