Compare prices within the same model year
2017
The BMW i8 market shows significant depreciation from its original MSRP, with average prices settling around $51,000. While a wide price range exists ($36k-$204k), the majority of listings fall within a more accessible bracket, indicating a strong downward trend for most models. However, exceptionally low-mileage or pristine examples may command premium prices, suggesting a bifurcated market where condition and mileage are paramount drivers of value.
Moderate
The BMW i8 market presents a compelling opportunity for buyers seeking a futuristic supercar experience at a depreciated price point. With an average price around $51,000 and a wide range of listings, patience and careful evaluation are key. Prioritize vehicles with lower mileage, as this significantly impacts value and future maintenance costs. While earlier models (2015) offer lower entry prices, they tend to have higher mileage. Newer models (2017) often represent a better balance of condition and price. Be prepared for a wide spectrum of pricing, from heavily used examples to near-mint, low-mileage collector cars.
This deal stands out with the highest deal score, significantly lower mileage than average (23,853 vs. 48,036), and substantial estimated savings of $25,527. It's a prime example of a well-priced, low-mileage modern supercar.
This listing boasts the second-highest deal score and offers the largest estimated savings among all deals ($26,529). With mileage well below average (27,897), it presents a fantastic opportunity for a buyer looking for significant value.
Ranked third, this 2016 model offers a solid deal score with mileage (32,126) that is still below the market average. While the estimated savings are not as dramatic as the top two, it represents a good value proposition for a well-maintained example.
This 2017 i8 is a strong contender with below-average mileage (28,084) and significant estimated savings ($16,538). Its short time on market (35 days) suggests it's a desirable vehicle, and the price is competitive for its condition.
This 2015 model is priced very competitively for its mileage (31,500), which is below the average for its year. Although estimated savings are low, its long days on market (260) suggest potential negotiation room, making it a good value pick.
This 2016 i8 offers a good balance with mileage (31,389) well below the average. While estimated savings are minimal, the price is very close to the market average, suggesting it's fairly valued for its condition and mileage.
This 2017 model offers substantial estimated savings ($12,726) and mileage (39,988) that, while higher than some, is still reasonable for its year and below the overall market average. Its long days on market (283) indicate potential for negotiation.
This 2015 BMW i8 from a reputable dealer is priced very attractively for its mileage (51,277), which is only slightly above the market average. Its relatively short time on market (54 days) suggests it's a solid offering.
This is the most affordable option within the top 15 deals, priced significantly below the average. While it has higher mileage (64,218), the substantial estimated savings ($8,290) and long days on market (232) make it a prime candidate for negotiation.
This 2016 model is priced very close to the market average, but its mileage (42,400) is below average, making it a fair deal. The short time on market (43 days) indicates it's a well-priced vehicle.
This is the absolute lowest-priced BMW i8 in the dataset, offering significant savings. Despite higher mileage (66,709), its rapid sale (42 days) indicates strong buyer interest at this price point, making it a great value for budget-conscious buyers.
This 2015 i8 is priced attractively below the market average. Although it has higher mileage (68,211), it represents a solid entry point into i8 ownership, especially with its 60 days on market suggesting it's been available for negotiation.
This 2016 i8 is priced near the market average, with mileage (57,285) that is higher but still acceptable for its age. Its extended time on market (177 days) suggests there may be room for negotiation.
This 2016 i8 is priced very close to the market average, with mileage (57,157) that is slightly above average but still acceptable. Its long days on market (158) might offer some negotiation leverage.
This 2015 i8 is priced significantly below the market average. While it has higher mileage (58,782), its very short time on market (4 days) suggests it's a highly desirable vehicle at this price point, indicating strong value.
Last analyzed: February 1, 2026