24 dealers ratedUpdated
Luxury and exotic car dealers in Indiana
24 dealers in 15 cities across Indiana with 5 or more luxury or exotic cars for sale, and how each one prices them.
"vs. market" is the median asking price against our fair value for the same cars; "Cars cut" is the share of each lot that has had a price cut while for sale.
Indiana dealers by cars for sale
| Dealer | City | Cars | Top brands | vs. market | Cars cut |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HyperCars | New Albany | 54 | Nissan, Lamborghini, McLaren | +7.0% | 6% |
| Bentley Indianapolis | Indianapolis | 45 | Lamborghini, Porsche, Mercedes-Benz | −2.9% | 49% |
| Auto Giant USA - Fishers | Fishers | 22 | Porsche, Tesla, Rivian | At market | 27% |
| Unlimited Motors - Westfield | Westfield | 22 | Mercedes-Benz, Porsche, BMW | At market | 41% |
| Fishers Imports Northwest | Indianapolis | 21 | BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Rivian | At market | 67% |
| Fishers Imports | Fishers | 17 | BMW, Bentley, Chevrolet | At market | 53% |
| SweetCars | Fort Wayne | 14 | Chevrolet, Porsche, Dodge | +1.9% | 36% |
| Unlimited Motors - Elwood | Elwood | 9 | Chevrolet, Mercedes-Benz, BMW | At market | 56% |
| Foreign Auto Connect | Bloomington | 8 | BMW, Porsche, Audi | At market | 63% |
| Northside Auto | Indianapolis | 7 | Tesla, Porsche, Rivian | At market | 0% |
| Unlimited Motors | Lafayette | 7 | Ford, Chevrolet, Porsche | −3.3% | 0% |
| Gator Motorsport | Indianapolis | 6 | Dodge, Alfa Romeo, Aston Martin | +7.7% | 33% |
| Highend Motors - Merrillville | Merrillville | 6 | BMW, Audi, Lamborghini | +2.8% | 17% |
| Highend Motors 2 | Merrillville | 6 | Chevrolet, Mercedes-Benz, BMW | +4.4% | 17% |
| Lakeside Chevrolet | Warsaw | 6 | Chevrolet | At market | 33% |
| Toyota of Muncie | Muncie | 6 | BMW, Chevrolet, Audi | +3.0% | 0% |
| AutoGiant USA | Indianapolis | 5 | Bentley, Chevrolet, Mercedes-Benz | −2.7% | 40% |
| City Automall | Columbia City | 5 | Ford, Chevrolet | At market | 20% |
| Driven Motorworks | Anderson | 5 | Tesla, Acura, Lamborghini | – | 0% |
| Indy Auto Man - Westfield | Westfield | 5 | Chevrolet, Audi, Ford | −1.6% | 60% |
| Indy Luxury Motorsports | Indianapolis | 5 | BMW, Chevrolet, Ford | At market | 80% |
| Lux Motors | Evansville | 5 | Aston Martin, BMW, Chevrolet | −2.0% | 40% |
| Noblesville Imports | Noblesville | 5 | BMW, Chevrolet, McLaren | +3.5% | 40% |
| Unlimited Motors | Westfield | 5 | Acura, Audi, BMW | −4.9% | 60% |
Dealers in other states
- Dealers in Alabama7
- Dealers in Arizona47
- Dealers in Arkansas3
- Dealers in California210
- Dealers in Colorado22
- Dealers in Connecticut9
- Dealers in Florida195
- Dealers in Georgia70
- Dealers in Hawaii5
- Dealers in Illinois80
- Dealers in Kansas9
- Dealers in Kentucky4
- Dealers in Maryland13
- Dealers in Massachusetts23
- Dealers in Michigan19
- Dealers in Minnesota5
- Dealers in Mississippi4
- Dealers in Missouri12
- Dealers in Nebraska7
- Dealers in Nevada21
- Dealers in New Hampshire3
- Dealers in New Jersey46
- Dealers in New Mexico5
- Dealers in New York28
- Dealers in North Carolina47
- Dealers in Ohio30
- Dealers in Oklahoma10
- Dealers in Oregon14
- Dealers in Pennsylvania20
- Dealers in Rhode Island3
- Dealers in South Carolina7
- Dealers in Tennessee21
- Dealers in Texas128
- Dealers in Utah25
- Dealers in Virginia44
- Dealers in Washington25
- Dealers in Wisconsin5
Indiana dealers: common questions
Which Indiana dealers have the most luxury and exotic cars for sale?
Right now: HyperCars in New Albany (54 cars), Bentley Indianapolis in Indianapolis (45 cars), and Auto Giant USA - Fishers in Fishers (22 cars).
Which Indiana dealers price closest to market?
Against our fair values for the same cars, the lowest asking prices are at Unlimited Motors (−4.9%), Unlimited Motors (−3.3%), and Bentley Indianapolis (−2.9%). A whole lot listed well under market can mean fees or financing-only prices, so ask each dealer for the out-the-door price.
How does Luxury Car Deals rate dealers?
From the cars dealers list for sale, not from reviews: each asking price against our fair value for the same car, the price cuts we record and how long cars stay listed.